Myths about acquired brain injury

Read about some of the misunderstandings people have about acquired brain injury.

This section talks about some of the misunderstandings people may have about acquired brain injury.

The people around a family may have some ideas about acquired brain injury that might not necessarily be the case. Examples and explanations follow:

‘Kids are so young – surely they can bounce back from anything?’

Some may think a child’s fast-growing brain can ‘bounce back’ after being injured. For many years, experts thought a younger brain was more ‘plastic’, and better able to work around the injury. But many researchers now think it isn’t quite so simple.1

The brain may be able to find new ways of doing things2 around the injured part. But this may mean the rest of the brain is having to work that much harder to make up for it.3

It’s also important to remember that an injury in childhood can interrupt the brain before it’s had the chance to pick up some very important skills,4, 5 and that an injury can make it very difficult for children to go on to pick up these skills.6, 7

Another important point is that while a child may appear to have ‘bounced back’ at first, there may be difficulties that aren’t easy to spot8. And some of these might take some time to come to the surface.9

But it is important to remember that nobody can rule out the dramatic improvements many children make. These biological issues about the brain are just part of a very big story.

Researchers believe a child’s environment – which includes their family – has a big role to play in a child’s recovery. Evidence suggests a supportive family environment can make a positive difference.10, 11  

‘Would a younger child cope with a brain injury better than an older child?’

Like a lot of questions about acquired brain injury, the answer is, ‘it’s complicated’. The reason for this is that the experts don’t always agree.12

One argument is that younger children aren’t as far along in their development. And their injury has the effect of ‘interrupting’ them while they are still learning. So they don’t have as many skills or as much experience to cope with their injury.13

We also know a brain injury can make picking up new skills difficult.14, 15 So this may make it more difficult for a younger child to learn the skills an older child may already have.16

But this isn’t the only view. Some researchers believe a younger brain is more ‘plastic’ and better able to find new ways of doing things.12 
To make things even more complicated, it’s very difficult to work out from just one ‘strand’ of brain injury – such as a child’s age – how that child will be affected. There are lots of other things to consider, like how severe the injury is12, how much rehabilitation there is, and a child’s home environment.11

But there is one thing that many researchers agree on: the importance of a child’s family environment in their recovery.10, 11

Watch our video on the impact of ABI on children from occupational therapist Lorna Wales:

References

  1. Baldwin T, Demellweek C, Rankin P, Carleton F (2006). Cognitive problems. In Appleton R, Baldwin T (Eds.), Management of Brain-injured Children (pp171-222). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  2. Haywood S (2010). The late medical complications of severe acquired brain injury in children – literature review and personal practice. Neurology, 16 (1), pp1-7.
  3. Baldwin T, Demellweek C, Rankin P, Carleton F (2006). Cognitive problems. In Appleton R, Baldwin T (Eds.), Management of Brain-injured Children (pp171-222). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  4. Walker S (2009). Educational Implications of Acquired Brain Injury: a resource for educational psychologists. Brain and Spine Foundation, p15.
  5. Baldwin T, Demellweek C, Rankin P, Carleton F (2006). Cognitive problems. In Appleton R, Baldwin T (Eds.), Management of Brain-injured Children (pp171-222). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  6. Walker S (2009). Educational Implications of Acquired Brain Injury: a resource for educational psychologists. Brain and Spine Foundation. Rees SA, Skidmore D (2008). The classical classroom: enhancing learning for pupils with acquired brain injury. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 2 (8) pp88-95.
  7. McCormick A, Curiale A, Aubut J, Weiser M, Marshall S. Paediatric interventions in acquired brain injury rehabilitation, Evidence-based Review of Moderate to Severe Acquired Brain Injury <www.abiebr.com > [consulted 15/12/11], PDF p7.
  8. Middleton, JA (2001). Brain injury in children and adolescents. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment , 7, pp257-265. Walker S (2009). Educational Implications of Acquired Brain Injury: a resource for educational psychologists. Brain and Spine Foundation. Henderson N, Kinley E, Loughran S (2006). Assessment and management of physical (motor and functional) difficulties. In Appleton R, Baldwin T (Eds.), Management of Brain-injured Children (pp107-139). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  9. Baldwin T, Demellweek C, Rankin P, Carleton F (2006). Cognitive problems. In Appleton R, Baldwin T (Eds.), Management of Brain-injured Children (pp171-222). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Middleton, JA (2001). Brain injury in children and adolescents. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment , 7, pp257-265. Walker S (2009). Educational Implications of Acquired Brain Injury: a resource for educational psychologists. Brain and Spine Foundation, p7.
  10. Taylor HG, Yeates KO, Wade SL, Droctar D, Stancin T and Burant C (2001). Bidirectional child-family influences on outcomes of traumatic brain injury in children. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 7, pp755-767. Taylor HG, Drotar D, Wade S, Yeates K, Stancin T, Klein S (1996) Recovery from Traumatic Brain Injury in Children: The Importance of the Family. In Broman SH and Michel ME (Eds.), Traumatic Head Injury in Children (pp 188-216). Oxford: Oxford University Press, (p189) Kinsella G, Ong B, Murtagh D, Prior M and Sawyer M (1999). The Role of the Family for Behavioural Outcome in Children and Adolescents Following Traumatic Brain Injury. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 67 (1), pp116-123. McCormick A, Curiale A, Aubut J, Weiser M, Marshall S. Paediatric interventions in acquired brain injury rehabilitation, Evidence-based Review of Moderate to Severe Acquired Brain Injury <www.abiebr.com > [consulted 15/12/11], PDF p24.
  11. Forsyth RJ (2010). Back to the Future: Rehabilitation of Children After Brain Injury. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 95, pp554-559.
  12. Anderson V, Catroppa C, Morese S, Haritou F, Rosenfeld J (2005). Functional Plasticity or Vulnerability After Early Brain Injury? Pediatrics, 6 (116), pp1374-1382.
  13. Anderson VA, Catroppa C, Morse SA, Haritou and Rosenfeld J (2000). Recovery of intellectual ability following traumatic brain injury in childhood: Impact of injury severity and age at injury. Paediatric Neurosurgery (32), pp282-290.
  14. Baldwin T, Demellweek C, Rankin P, Carleton F (2006). Cognitive problems. In Appleton R, Baldwin T (Eds.), Management of Brain-injured Children (pp171-222). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  15. Savage RC, Depompei R, Tyler J, Lash M (2005) Paediatric traumatic brain injury: A review of pertinent issues. Pediatric rehabilitation, 8 (2), pp92-103.
  16. Rees SA, Skidmore D (2008). The classical classroom: enhancing learning for pupils with acquired brain injury. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 2 (8) pp88-95. Walker S (2009). Educational Implications of Acquired Brain Injury: a resource for educational psychologists. Brain and Spine Foundation, p15. p15.